Why so many people talk about Shane Warne's ball of the century?
Because it did something that broadened our horizon. The ball did
something that mere mortals couldn't grasp. But does it defies the laws of physics? My answer is NO. The event occurred in a space which only Warne could maneouver, we can
appreciate its beauty but cannot access it. Here, I make an humble attempt to see such rare things from a physicists point of view.
When physicists talk about natural phenomena, they generally ask
questions such as, “what are the typical length scales and time
scales associated with it ?”. For example, one length scale in
cricket could be the 22 yards pitch length, it could be the diameter
of the ball, it could be the width of bat. We know how the transition
from back foot no ball calling to front foot no ball calling has
changed the game by changing the pitch length. A modern day follower
will agree that the thickness of bat and reduced boundary size has
given us more DLF maximums. The reaction time the batsman gets to a
90 mph ball can be used as a time scale. So, speed is distance
divided by time or time is distance by speed. So if we divide 22
yards by 90 mph, we get a reaction time of 0.138 seconds. Now that is
the quantity when commentators say, “its only a fraction of
seconds.” With in 0.138 seconds can we make a decision to think and
execute the right thing over a period of more than 24 years, with
injuries, pressures from media, youngsters, captains, coaches and
fans. That is why CLR James said all great batsmen are rare
individuals and they are not many. Sachin Tendulkar is truely one of
them. In fact none of the international players in any sport are mere
mortals like you and me. No one needs a degree in physics to
understand the introduction to classical mechanics given
by Prof V. Balakrishnan.
It might change the way you look at the world around you.
Now the situation is even more complex. The time is not always 0.138
s, the bowlers vary their speeds. One thing is to know the average
number and another thing is to know how many factors it depends on
and how? For example, the time period of a simple pendulum depends
only on its length, acceleration due to gravity and not on its mass.
You will find a lovely demonstration,
by one of the most loved teacher in the world. In cricket, roughly
saying, the outcome of a ball depends on what the bowler has created
and how the batsman has reacted to it. A bowler can change the speed
of the ball, direction of seam, amount and direction of rotation,
position on the delivery crease and position of arm. All the above
parameters effectively decide three physical things, initial
position, linear momentum and angular momentum imparted to the ball.
The three things can be understood in analogy with your vehicle. Your
current location is your position, your speed on straight roads is
linear velocity. Multiply it by the weight of your car and you get
linear momentum. Your speed while turning multiplied by the weight
and the arc radius gives angular momentum. Fatal accidents occur when
you are not with in the recommended limit of these 3 quantities.
Alcohol needless to say enhances tha danger by provoking you to break
the limits.
Back to cricket. A batsman similarly reacts by varying the point
and time of impact between bat and ball, varying the angle of bat to
manipulate gaps and simply swing harder to generate power. To an
event already depending on many things, nature adds its own
contribution of moisture, cloud, grass and dew. So many variables.
This is an interesting viewpoint to look at cricket, I feel. Let me
share with you. The discussion is subjective only. May be perhaps 100
years down the line science would be competent enough to give numbers
to justify all its claims by concrete numbers. But then the fun of unpredictability would be somewhat lost, isn't it? With this humble
warning let's proceed.
We will all agree, unlike football or field hockey, cricket is a sort
of a semi-dynamic phenomena. There is breathing space between every
ball, time enough to sledge or walk away to square leg umpire and
comeback. Let us treat each ball as an isolated phenomena. This is
certainly not true other than some specific cases such as if the
batsman is in his “zone” or he is Virender Sehwag. At a
psychological level, what happened in the last ball, how you got
dismissed by a particular bowler in the last innings, who your
partner is, is it Hobart or Nagpur, match situation etc., affects the
batsman’s approach to the game. But it is also true what goes
inside a player’s mind manifests in terms of physical observables,
such as footwork, drift on the ball, angles he is creating.
Commentators, former players and analysts, might tell you how did the
player manages to do so. Some of the details that former Test opener
Aakash Chopra brings out
here, it feels like the player might not have thought about them himself.
But all eyes are not equally not trained.
Let us extend our discussion along the lines of our opening paragraph
and discuss in bit more detail the event of an isolated ball. We can
start from the run-up and go till the finish of follow through. These
are important things, but for the purpose of current discussion I
look at it in this way.
At the time of release, what a bowler can give to the ball? Spin by
rotating wrist or finger, seam and swing by subtle wrist position,
speed, bounce. As I said earlier, in terms of physical quantities,
all these effects can be described as linear velocity for speed,
angular velocity for rotation and initial position and applied force
for bounce/zip. Once the ball is released nature comes into play. A
cricket ball’s mass, diameter falls in the range of classical
mechanics or Newtonian mechanics. It is a range within which we can
differentiate between slower and faster, smaller and bigger things.
The other two extremes of nature being covered by quantum mechanics
and general theory of relativity. One can calculate deBroglie wavelength for cricket ball and it is surely be larger than the human
eye resolution power which makes quantum effects negligible and we
surely know it doesn't travel at the speed of light. Classical
mechanics is the range where human intuition works.
Remember your school physics problems, where you were asked to find
the the position of car at any time, given you know where it start
from and how fast it is accelerating. using Newton’s laws of
motion. The equation F=m*a, still remains valid in cricket but what
makes predicting the trajectory of the ball difficult from high
school problems are the assumptions we generally skip in our
textbooks. We have to correctly take into account the natural factors
such as air resistance, dampness of the pitch. It is no secret that
even a skilled practitioner cannot do much with ball if the external
factors are highly against him. For example, on a rank turner
Ravindra Jadeja is almost unplayable. So, a batsman watches closely
the finger of the bowler and makes immediate judgment about line and
length about the ball taking all that pitch and air could have done
into count. What makes elite sportsmen different than academicians
who can explain drift from Magnus effect or swing from Bernoulli’s
equation, is a natural ability to recognize, analyse and sample the
available phase space better and of course, they train hard to
strengthen that ability so that they can perform consistently under
match condition. For people like us, it is only appreciating that a
wrist movement takes the ball from mid-on to square leg. But we
cannot simply do it. We cannot tell how much degree wrist has moved
in clockwise/anti-clockwise direction without doing calculation in
the comfortable environment of our workspace. A VVS Laxman, on the
other hand, has this intrinsic knowledge about his maximum and
minimum accessible degrees and within that range he can maneuver as
swiftly as he wishes. It is an enormous task that a human mind
accomplishes by training. To watch a 140 kph ball from 22 yards and
predict its final location, to go forward/backward, to go
inside/behind/outside the line of the ball, is almost like solving a
9*9 sudoku puzzle within fraction of seconds. We stand in awe, in
admiration and rightly so because this is something 99% of us cannot
do. Don’t believe me? Try landing leg spin in an rectangular strip
3 out of 6 times. It looks like magic when Shane Warne does it. It
looks like magic when reverse swinging yorkers strike the base of the
stumps.
Great words have been written by great men in favor of cricket as an
art form, none did it more convincingly than C. L. R. James in his
seminal work “Beyond a Boundary”. One of my favorite columnist Andrew Hughes gives a nice summary of the arguments here. I believe it is an art at the
surface but science holds its own in the background. And both give
pretty enjoyable pictures. As physicist Richard Feynman once said the
knowledge of intrinsic cellular detail only adds to the aesthetic
feeling of beauty of a flower, a poet may put in better words though.
One last video to appreciate beauty in nature.
No comments:
Post a Comment