If Virender
Sehwag gets the chance to play Test cricket again, it would mean that the
present generations have failed big time and Indian cricket is going backward
to find a solution. That’s unlikely to happen, and is not good for the health
for Indian cricket as well. Whether he returns or not that won’t change
anything, he has given us enough memories to cherish about.
According
to John Wright, “He didn’t redefine his game because of his batting position.
He redefined the position with his batting.” One cannot disagree with this simple
yet strong statement. Aakash Chopra,
probably the finest cricket writer amongst Indian test cricketers, goes one
step further by saying, “It would be fair to say that opening in Test match
cricket can be divided into two eras-pre-Sehwag and post-Sehwag.” Sehwag has literally
inspired David Warner into test cricket and his performances have inspired captains
and coaches to try players like Tilakaratne Dilshan and Shane Watson as test
openers. Without Sehwag’s success and more importantly success with his method,
it is difficult to imagine test debut of the mentioned players.
He has
shown others it is possible to score more than run-a-ball in test cricket and
that too for an extended period. An opener with more than 14 scores in excess
of 150 or more out of 23 hundreds with a career strike rate of 82.23, Dileep Premachandran’s
observation of Sehwag as a sprinter with a marathon runner’s stamina is more
than appropriate.
There
have been many excellent articles written about Sehwag, his method and the
visual delight he gives to an audience. What I intend to do here is a mere
number based comparison to show where Sehwag stands among the greats of his
time. I consider the players who have scored more than 6000 runs at an average
of more than 45 after Sehwag’s debut. The reason behind putting the constraint
on the time period is that at least we are reducing few variables (i.e. the condition
of pitches, batting equipment, rules and regulations) from the many variable
space on which a measure of batting greatness possibly depends. So, the statistical error, and the absurdity
of comparison based on numbers decreases.
So, the
list contains 19 players who have dominated test cricket in last 15 years. The temptation
to include Inzamam-Ul-Haq, Steve Waugh and particularly Brian Lara in a list
which already contains Ponting, Tendulkar, Kallis and Dravid was very hard to
avoid but I stuck to the list of 19 players. The list is arranged in the
descending order of batting average.
Serial No.
|
Name
|
Runs
|
Average
|
1
|
K Sangakkara
|
10368
|
60.27
|
2
|
J Kallis
|
9949
|
59.22
|
3
|
S Chanderpaul
|
8386
|
58.23
|
4
|
R Ponting
|
10548
|
54.93
|
5
|
M Hayden
|
7306
|
53.72
|
6
|
Y Khan
|
6575
|
53.45
|
7
|
AB de Villiers
|
7168
|
51.94
|
8
|
R Dravid
|
9255
|
51.7
|
9
|
M Hussey
|
6235
|
51.52
|
10
|
M Clarke
|
8240
|
51.5
|
11
|
S Tendulkar
|
9002
|
51.44
|
12
|
H Amla
|
6214
|
51.35
|
13
|
M Jayawardene
|
8853
|
51.17
|
14
|
V Sehwag
|
8586
|
49.34
|
15
|
VVS Laxman
|
7343
|
48.62
|
16
|
G. smith
|
9265
|
48.25
|
17
|
A Cook
|
8181
|
47.28
|
18
|
K Pietersen
|
8047
|
46.51
|
19
|
I Bell
|
6722
|
45.41
|
Table 1:
List of all the players who have scored more than 6000 test runs at an average
of 45 or more after Sehwag’s debut test match (03.11.2001).
As it
turns out Sangakkara, Kallis and Chanderpaul lead the way with overall average
while Ponting has scored more runs than any other in the mentioned time
interval. In an unrelated note, there is nothing much to separate between the
numbers of two Indian legends, Dravid and Tendulkar. Sehwag occupies 14th
spot in the list and more importantly only one of the three openers in the
list, Matthew Hayden and Greame Smith being the other two.
There are
some common criticism against Sehwag’s performance which I have come across
while talking with friends and following the discussion of cricket community on
social platforms. This motivates me to break the numbers depending on the point
of argument and compare his number with those of the mentioned successful
batsmen of his generation.
(a) Flat track bully:
For this
purpose, I break down the overall average into home and away (and mutual venue
when Pakistan was one of the teams) average. This makes sense to me as we can
get a measure of success of a subcontinent player in pace friendly conditions
and also the ability of English, South African and Australian batsmen in
spinning tracks. The difference between the away and home average is calculated
which shows the relative adaptability of individual player. The results are
summarized in Table 2 (a). For the ease of comparison, the name of the players
are re-arranged in the decreasing order of difference in Table 2 (b).
Serial No.
|
Name
|
Home Average
(X)
|
Away + Neutral Venue Average
(Y)
|
Difference
D= (Y)-(X)
|
1
|
K Sangakkara
|
67.34
|
53.68
|
-13.66
|
2
|
J Kallis
|
63.56
|
54.55
|
-9.01
|
3
|
S Chanderpaul
|
66.06
|
52.14
|
-13.92
|
4
|
R Ponting
|
60.47
|
48.92
|
-11.55
|
5
|
M Hayden
|
62.29
|
42.52
|
-19.77
|
6
|
Y Khan
|
65.26
|
50.28
|
-14.98
|
7
|
AB de Villiers
|
45.85
|
59.85
|
14
|
8
|
R Dravid
|
51.3
|
51.96
|
0.66
|
9
|
M Hussey
|
61.19
|
41.37
|
-19.82
|
10
|
M Clarke
|
61.9
|
42.77
|
-19.13
|
11
|
S Tendulkar
|
46.85
|
55.57
|
8.72
|
12
|
H Amla
|
45.74
|
56.06
|
10.32
|
13
|
M Jayawardene
|
61.28
|
42.47
|
-18.81
|
14
|
V Sehwag
|
54.13
|
44.65
|
-9.48
|
15
|
VVS Laxman
|
55.75
|
44.88
|
-10.87
|
16
|
G smith
|
41.52
|
54.98
|
13.46
|
17
|
A Cook
|
52.75
|
41.88
|
-10.87
|
18
|
K Pietersen
|
43.55
|
49.93
|
6.38
|
19
|
I Bell
|
53.68
|
38
|
-15.68
|
Table 2
(a): Performance difference of players in home and away matches.
Serial No.
|
Name
|
Difference
D= (Y)-(X)
|
1
|
AB de Villiers
|
14
|
2
|
G smith
|
13.46
|
3
|
H Amla
|
10.32
|
4
|
S Tendulkar
|
8.72
|
5
|
K Pietersen
|
6.38
|
6
|
R Dravid
|
0.66
|
7
|
J Kallis
|
-9.01
|
8
|
V Sehwag
|
-9.48
|
9
|
VVS Laxman
|
-10.87
|
10
|
A Cook
|
-10.87
|
11
|
R Ponting
|
-11.55
|
12
|
K Sangakkara
|
-13.66
|
13
|
S Chanderpaul
|
-13.92
|
14
|
Y Khan
|
-14.98
|
15
|
I Bell
|
-15.68
|
16
|
M Jayawardene
|
-18.81
|
17
|
M Clarke
|
-19.13
|
18
|
M Hayden
|
-19.77
|
19
|
M Hussey
|
-19.82
|
Table 2
(b): Re-arrangement of Table 2(a) in the decreasing order of difference (D)
between away and home matches.
What the
difference column shows us that only 6 players in the list have a positive
difference i.e. better away record. The list is headed by 3 South Africans (de Villiers,
Smith and Amla) and the 3 bottom places are occupied by 3 Australians (Hussey,
Hayden and Clarke). Rahul Dravid is the batsman whose numbers vary the least
with respect to conditions. Sehwag is placed at No. 8 in the list. But based on
the difference it would be misleading to say he is a better away performer than
Sangakkara or Ponting, his absolute away average is still lower than them. What
it shows the relative measure of a player’s own performance in home and away
matches. But to suggest that Sehwag is a flat track bulley is no more
meaningful than to suggest Hussey and Clarke are lesser player of spin bowling.
(b) First innings specialist:
From
outset it is easy to expect that Sehwag’s or most of the player’s second
innings average will be less than their first innings average. In order to get
a quantitative picture, the overall average is broken down into 2 innings and
the comparison is shown in Fig. 3(a). Like the earlier case, we calculate the
difference between 2nd innings and 1st innings average,
and rearrange the players in the descending order of difference in Table 3(b).
Serial No.
|
Name
|
1st Innings
Average
(X)
|
2nd Innings
Average
(Y)
|
Difference
D= (Y)-(X)
|
1
|
K Sangakkara
|
62.21
|
57.32
|
-4.89
|
2
|
J Kallis
|
58.53
|
60.45
|
1.92
|
3
|
S Chanderpaul
|
64.64
|
49
|
-15.64
|
4
|
R Ponting
|
59.96
|
46.73
|
-13.23
|
5
|
M Hayden
|
51.2
|
57.53
|
6.33
|
6
|
Y Khan
|
54.69
|
51.64
|
-3.05
|
7
|
AB de Villiers
|
56.38
|
44.81
|
-11.57
|
8
|
R Dravid
|
59.72
|
39.67
|
-20.05
|
9
|
M Hussey
|
55.12
|
45.87
|
-9.25
|
10
|
M Clarke
|
57.79
|
41.54
|
-16.25
|
11
|
S Tendulkar
|
58.44
|
39.86
|
-18.58
|
12
|
H Amla
|
48.68
|
55.35
|
6.67
|
13
|
M Jayawardene
|
60.93
|
36.1
|
-24.83
|
14
|
V Sehwag
|
62.5
|
30.25
|
-32.25
|
15
|
VVS Laxman
|
48.01
|
49.77
|
1.76
|
16
|
G smith
|
49.63
|
46.19
|
-3.44
|
17
|
A Cook
|
53.49
|
38.38
|
-15.11
|
18
|
K Pietersen
|
47.28
|
45.43
|
-1.85
|
19
|
I Bell
|
51.04
|
37.16
|
-13.88
|
Table 3
(a): Performance difference of players in 1st and 2nd
innings of match.
Serial No.
|
Name
|
Difference
D= (Y)-(X)
|
1
|
H
Amla
|
6.67
|
2
|
M
Hayden
|
6.33
|
3
|
J
Kallis
|
1.92
|
4
|
VVS
Laxman
|
1.76
|
5
|
K
Pietersen
|
-1.85
|
6
|
Y
Khan
|
-3.05
|
7
|
G
smith
|
-3.44
|
8
|
K
Sangakkara
|
-4.89
|
9
|
M
Hussey
|
-9.25
|
10
|
AB
de Villiers
|
-11.57
|
11
|
R
Ponting
|
-13.23
|
12
|
I
Bell
|
-13.88
|
13
|
A
Cook
|
-15.11
|
14
|
S
Chanderpaul
|
-15.64
|
15
|
M
Clarke
|
-16.25
|
16
|
S
Tendulkar
|
-18.58
|
17
|
R
Dravid
|
-20.05
|
18
|
M
Jayawardene
|
-24.83
|
19
|
V Sehwag
|
-32.25
|
Table 3
(b): Re-arrangement of Table 3(a) in the decreasing order of difference (D)
between 2nd innings and 1st innings average
Hashim
Amla leads the way this time, followed by Matthew Hayden and Jack Kallis. It
comes as no surprise that VVS Laxman, the crisis man, has the highest
difference as well as the highest absolute 2nd innings average
(49.77) amongst the Indian batsmen. He is roughly 10 runs clear ahead of Dravid
and Tendulkar. Sehwag is at the bottom of the list, both in terms of 2nd
innings average and the difference. In fact his first innings average (62.5) is
more than twice that of his 2nd innings average (30.25). It’s not really
a bad thing to do the bulk of scoring in the first innings and set the game up
for your team. The numbers really confirm the notion that Sehwag is not the man
for epic 2nd innings chases, memorable rear-guard performances.
This is by no means a complete analysis. In fact, what I believe, a fractionally better idea to test (only statistically) the consistency of a player, is to break his numbers into several sections, based on his performances
·
Against all the oppositions
·
On all the countries
·
During each year of his carrier
Say for
the third heading, we will get Sehwag’s average in each of his seasons. Then we
can have an idea about the standard deviation of his all year averages and the
mean is of course his career average. A player with maximum mean supposed to be
the best (only statistically) of his time (in this case Sangakkara), while a
minimum standard deviation is a measure of his consistency. Though most of the
players go through purple patches and lean patches, and the height and depth of
these crests and troughs will affect the standard deviation. This can be
repeated for all the 3 headings mentioned earlier. But, for the time being I
restrain myself from such a crazy and even meaningless number crunching.
It’s true
to certain extent that numbers don’t lie but at the same time they don’t tell
the complete story either. For people of our generation will fail to understand
why with a career average of 39.62, Victor Trumper is considered as the first
great batsman from Australia and almost always preceded by the word “immortal”.
The sheer joy, the anxiety, the air of unpredictability and the frustration
when they got out, makes player like Sehwag inaccessible to numbers. Our
generation can consider ourselves very fortunate to see Virender Sehwag’s batting,
that is an experience to tell our grandchildren. Long live Virender Sehwag,
your memories will remain with us.
Nice one :)
ReplyDeleteThank you :)
Delete